Well, I've done 2 oil changes with it now - our 08 Tribeca (Fumoto Valve, Horizontal spin-on filter underneath) and a 2006 Yaris (standard drain bolt, vertical spin-on fliter).

I would say it handles splatter pretty well. It's nice and deep at the drain point, a little shallower, but still deeper than many further out. I didn't spill a drop with the 'Beca (thanks fumoto!) even with the high-up oil filter splattering down. I did spill a bit with the Yaris - the drain bolt points towards the passenger tire and there isn't enough room to get the deep part of the pan underneath that area, so I had some splatter. Maybe I'll use a floor jack instead of ramps the next time. So I guess the only mark against the pan is that it's a bit bigger (but not huge by any means).

Also, it had room to spare after both oil changes (probably almost 11 quarts between the 2), although I did empty it out into my 5 gallon drum as I have another oil change to do on Sunday morning.